Previous
Giftedness often evokes certain images: the genius who effortlessly gets high grades, a chessboard on the table, and a university degree at a young age. However, the reality is much more nuanced. There are many misconceptions about giftedness that can lead to misunderstanding, underestimation, or unnecessary frustration. In the context of the Week of Giftedness, I would like to discuss some of the biggest misconceptions.
Misconception 1: Giftedness always means high performance
One of the most persistent misconceptions is that gifted individuals automatically excel in school or at work. In reality, gifted individuals can struggle due to lack of challenge, motivation issues, or perfectionism. This can lead to underperformance or even a bore-out. Research by Rimm (2008) shows that underperformance is common among gifted children, with causes ranging from a non-challenging learning environment to social adjustment to peers.
Gifted individuals often have a great thirst for learning, but if the material is too repetitive or too simple, they quickly lose motivation. This can cause them to disengage or even give up. As a result, their talents are not always recognized, and they may be unfairly labeled as unmotivated or lazy. Creating a stimulating environment is crucial to help their potential flourish.
Misconception 2: Gifted individuals don’t need help or guidance
Because gifted individuals are often seen as 'smart enough,' it's sometimes assumed that they can manage on their own. But intellectual abilities don’t automatically mean someone can deal well with emotions, social dynamics, or task organization. Moon (2002) emphasizes that gifted individuals benefit from guidance focused on social and emotional development because they often struggle with intense emotions and a strong sense of justice.
Many gifted individuals experience a gap between their intellectual abilities and their social or emotional development. For example, they may think deeply about moral issues but struggle to regulate their own emotions. Guidance and coaching can help bridge this gap and support them in finding a balanced way to handle their intensities.
Misconception 3: Gifted individuals always have a high IQ
Although a high IQ is a characteristic of giftedness, it's not just about intelligence. Renzulli’s (2005) model of giftedness suggests that it’s a combination of high intellectual abilities, creativity, and task commitment. This means that not everyone with a high IQ is gifted, and some gifted individuals may not excel in traditional IQ tests.
Creativity and perseverance play an equally important role in giftedness. Some gifted individuals struggle with standard tests because they think differently or make complex connections that don't fit neatly into normative measurement methods. As a result, they may be unfairly excluded from the official definition of giftedness, while still experiencing the same needs and challenges.
Misconception 4: Gifted individuals are socially awkward
Some think that giftedness is synonymous with social awkwardness or being out of touch with the world. While some gifted individuals may struggle with social interactions, this is not true for everyone. Silverman (2013) suggests that many gifted individuals are actually very empathetic and sensitive but struggle to connect when conversations remain superficial. This can lead to feelings of loneliness, especially during childhood.
Many gifted individuals have a deeper need for meaningful conversations and connection. If they feel misunderstood, they may withdraw or present themselves differently to be accepted. This can cause them to adapt at the expense of their own needs, which may lead to identity issues and emotional exhaustion later in life.
Misconception 5: Gifted individuals can do everything if they just try hard enough
This belief puts unnecessary pressure on gifted individuals. Intelligence does not mean everything comes easily; they also need to develop skills, make an effort, and make mistakes. Dweck’s (2006) research on the 'growth mindset' shows that a static view of intelligence ('you’re either smart or not') is actually limiting and can lead to fear of failure and avoidance of challenges.
Gifted individuals may actually be afraid of making mistakes because they are used to things coming easily to them. When they face resistance, they may feel insecure or think they are failing. Therefore, it’s important for them to learn that growth involves trying, failing, and getting back up, just like everyone else.
Misconception 6: Giftedness is always an advantage
While giftedness has many positive aspects, it also presents challenges. The feeling of being 'different,' difficulty with routine tasks, and a constant hunger for stimulation can be tough. According to Webb et al. (2007), gifted individuals may be more sensitive to depression and existential crises because they think deeply about life and their role in it. Without the right environment, giftedness can be more of a source of frustration than an advantage.
That’s why it’s important not to view giftedness only as a talent but also as a specific way of functioning that requires understanding and support. When gifted individuals learn to better understand themselves and their needs and find an environment that supports them, they can use their talents in a healthy and fulfilling way.
As you can see, giftedness is more than just being smart. It’s a way of thinking, feeling, and experiencing that brings both advantages and challenges. Do you recognize these misconceptions or want more insight into giftedness? Feel free to get in touch for an informal conversation.